Both Savlon and Dettol and two popular, effective antiseptic. Millions of consumers seem to prefer them over other brands.
However, they are not the same. While Dettol has gained more popularity in recent decades, Savlon (based on reviews and testimonials) has proven to be a more effective antiseptic than dettol.
In this article, we’ll look at both antiseptic and which is better for watching.
Antimicrobial activity
If you’re looking to get a clean and disinfected kitchen, you may be wondering which of the two popular washing antibacterial products is better for you.
A recent study tested the antibacterial activity of Dettol, Savlon, and Lysol in a lab setting.
The difference between these products lies in their chemical compositions. Savlon is made with PCMX, a key component responsible for its brown color. The other products were inactive against these bacteria.
Both Savlon and Dettol are great antibacterial products, but they contain different active ingredients.
Savlon contains chlorhexidine gluconate, which are common disinfectants, and Dettol contains PCMX, which is a brown chemical. Dettol is more effective for washing clothing and floors, while Savlon is better for treating cuts and wounds.
Hydrogen peroxide and formalin were effective against all pathogens studied. However, Dettol’s antimicrobial activity against S. aureus and S. typhi was not significant.
Iodine was the only disinfectant that inhibited a significant number of pathogens but was effective against E. coli. Savlon and Dettol both inhibit the growth of gram-negative bacteria.
A comparison of the antimicrobial activity of Dettol and Savlon in a clinical setting has been conducted. The two products were tested using their minimum inhibitory concentrations against a variety of clinical organisms.
The tests used the Minimal Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) test, Capacity Use Dilution Test, and Bacterial Disinfection Activity (BACT) Method.
One study showed that both products had antimicrobial activity against a variety of pathogenic organisms, including the E. coli and Salmonella bacterium. The study also observed that both products were effective in the presence of excessive organic matter.
A study published in 1995 found that both disinfectants are effective when tested at their recommended concentrations. However, the test indicated that the antimicrobial activity was less than ten percent.
Sensitivity to hard water
When comparing two antibacterials for washing, the first thing to consider is how sensitive they are to hard water.
Hard water is found in 80 percent of U.S. homes. In fact, the water can inhibit the effectiveness of some types of disinfectants.
These products are especially effective in the presence of organic matter. To determine how sensitive they are to hard water, compare the MICs of Savlon and Dettol.
Both of these products have good bacterial and fungal inhibition activity. They are effective when used in the correct concentrations.
Savlon and Dettol were both effective in a capacity-use dilution test using P. aeruginosa.
Despite the difference in MICs, both products showed bactericidal activity after the first addition in the weakest dilution.
Savlon vs Dettol: Which is better?
Savlon is better for washing clothes and floors, but Dettol is good for treating wounds and removing itchy hair. But which one is better?
Both have antibacterial properties, but they do have different benefits for different types of people. If you have sensitive skin, Savlon will be a better choice, as it is mild and can be used on all skin types.
Despite being similar in nature, these two cleaning products have a different reputation. Savlon was the first antiseptic, but it failed as a brand and product because of its negative image as an “antiseptic.”
However, Dettol played the game better than Savlon did. Rather than focusing on its negative image, it took on the band-aid industry and the J&J company.
The company also positioned itself as a good brand.
When it comes to popularity, both brands have their positives and negatives. Savlon has the advantage in terms of buzz.
Savlon is more popular amongst the 35+ crowd, while Dettol is popular with the millennials. Dettol has more sales due to its reputation but is not as well-known as Savlon. Compared to Savlon, Dettol is more popular among generation Z.
The Savlon brand is relatively unknown in the Indian market, owing to its insignificant presence. Its rivalry with Dettol is due to the steep taxation on cigarette consumption.
But despite the low sales, the ITC’s strategy has proven to be profitable.
The company has already increased its sales by nearly tenfold since the acquisition of the Johnson & Johnson brand in 2015. Savlon’s expansion into the hand-wash segment and hand sanitizer category is a new focus for the brand.
Savlon vs Dettol: Conclusion
Keep in mind that both Savlon and Dettol are not equally effective in eliminating bacteria and yeast.
Despite their similar efficacy, savlon is more effective against Candida than other disinfectants.
It can eliminate contaminants such as Candida albicans in as little as 10 to 20 minutes.
This makes Savlon more preferred than Dettol for disinfecting surfaces. Its antibacterial properties help it to be a better choice for many applications.
